A young couple laughing at something on a phone

“What are we?”: how to ask in a situationship without losing yourself

You know their coffee order, their sister’s name and the song they skip every time, but you don’t know what to call them.

That is a strange place to live. You can be close to someone, laughing at the same memes at midnight, and still feel your stomach drop when a friend asks, “So what are you two, exactly?” You change the subject. You say “we’re just seeing where it goes”. And you go home with the question still sitting in your throat.

I am not here to tell you situationships are bad. Plenty of people enjoy something undefined, and plenty of good relationships began in exactly this grey space. The trouble starts when the not-knowing begins to cost you more than it gives. This post is for that moment.

“What are we?” is really two questions

When you ask “what are we?”, you are asking two things at once.

The first is: what is this for them? You cannot answer that one on your own, however many times you replay their messages.

The second is: what do I need this to be for me? That one you can answer, and it is worth answering first. If you go into the conversation knowing only that you want an answer, any answer will knock you off balance. If you go in knowing what you want, their answer becomes information you can do something with.

Why it can feel so risky to ask

Ambiguity is tiring for the body. You might notice you hold your breath before opening their message. Your shoulders go up when they reply late. You read the length of a text like a weather report. (If the waiting itself is the hard part, I wrote about what to do while you wait for a text back.)

A lot of people in situationships also start shrinking. You keep things light so you don’t seem “too much”. You stop mentioning that you’d like to meet on weekends, not just late at night. You laugh off the thing that hurt. Each small edit feels reasonable, and over a few months you can find yourself in a relationship where your needs have nowhere to sit. If that pattern sounds familiar from other parts of your life, I wrote about it in being good meant being invisible.

Asking is a way of putting yourself back in the picture. It is also, honestly, a kindness to both of you, because clarity gives the other person a chance to be honest too.

Before you ask: three minutes with yourself

Sit somewhere you won’t be interrupted and answer these, ideally on paper:

  1. What do I want this to be? Exclusive, a relationship with a name, something casual but more consistent, or are you not sure? “I don’t know yet” is a real answer.
  2. What would I do if the answer is not what I hope? You don’t have to decide now. Just notice whether you are hoping that asking will change their mind.
  3. Where in my body do I feel the question right now? Chest, throat, stomach, hands? Remember it. You’ll check again later.

Four ways to ask

There is no perfect script, and the right one depends on how long this has been going on and how much you already know. These run from light to direct. Use your own words, in whatever language feels most like you.

1. The check-in

“I’m really enjoying this. How are you thinking about it?”

Good for early on, when you mostly want to open the door. It invites them to say where they are without pinning anyone down. The risk: it is easy to answer vaguely, so notice whether you got an answer or a shrug.

2. The needs statement

“I’ve realised I’m someone who needs to know where I stand. Can we talk about what this is?”

This puts your need on the table without blaming them for it. You are telling them something true about yourself, and they can respond to that.

3. The choice

“I’d like this to be exclusive. If that isn’t what you want, I would honestly rather know.”

The most direct, and often the most freeing. You are saying what you want and making it safe for them to say no. It works best once you have done the three questions above and know you can hear a no.

4. The pause

“I need to step back for a bit while I think about what I want.”

Sometimes the clearest thing you can do is not ask them anything. If you keep getting vague answers, or you notice you are losing yourself, a pause gives you room to hear your own thoughts again. You can come back to the conversation later, or not.

A practical note: if you can, have this conversation in person or on a call rather than over text. Text gives both people time to edit, and it is very hard to read tone from a typing bubble.

Noticing your answer in your body afterwards

A woman looking at her phone by the water
Photo: Becca Tapert on Unsplash

This is the part people skip, and it is the part I care about most.

After they reply, and before you reply, pause. Take one slow breath and check in with three places:

  • Chest. Does it open, loosen, feel lighter? Or does it tighten, or feel heavy?
  • Jaw and throat. Are you clenching? Is there a lump, or words you are swallowing?
  • Stomach. A drop, a flutter, a settling, or nothing at all?

Then compare it with what you felt before you asked.

Relief, a sinking feeling, a tight throat, even numbness: each of these is information about what you want. None of them is a verdict on you or on them. Sometimes the body knows before the mind does, which is why I wrote a whole post on where people feel emotions in the body. A “yes, let’s be exclusive” that leaves your chest tight is worth paying attention to. So is an “I’m not looking for anything serious” that, to your surprise, makes your shoulders drop with relief.

You do not have to respond in the moment. It is completely okay to say, “Thank you for being honest. Can I think about this and talk to you tomorrow?” Taking that time gives your reply a chance to come from you, once the panic of the moment has passed.

If the answer isn’t what you hoped

It might hurt, even if part of you expected it. Let it. You asked a brave question and got an honest answer, and that counts for something, even when it doesn’t feel like a win.

Try to be as kind to yourself afterwards as you would be to a friend who had just done the same thing. Eat something. Call someone who knows you well. Notice where the hurt sits in your body, and put a warm hand there for a minute.

If you want to think more broadly about how you and a partner talk to each other, I have written about that in is communication the issue in your relationship?.

If asking doesn’t feel safe

If you are scared to ask because of how they might react, or if asking leads to pressure, threats, or someone trying to control who you see or what you do, that is not a communication problem to solve with better wording. Please talk to someone you trust and to a qualified professional. The note at the end of this post has a helpline if you need one.

What you have just read is psychoeducation: general information and reflection, written for a lot of people at once. It is not therapy, an assessment, or a diagnosis, and it is not advice about your particular situation. Reading it does not make us a practitioner and a client.

If you are carrying something heavy, please talk to a qualified mental health professional who can actually see you and your circumstances. And if you are in crisis or thinking about harming yourself, please do not start here. In India, Tele-MANAS is free and open 24 hours on 14416, in English and many Indian languages. Anywhere else, findahelpline.com has the number for your country.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top