A hand writing in a lined notebook

Why writing worry down can help (and when it doesn’t)

The best-known study on writing about hard things made people feel worse on the day they did it.

I like starting there, because so much of what gets said about journaling sounds like a promise. Write it down and feel lighter. Fifteen minutes and you’ll sleep better. The research is more honest than that, and in a way kinder, because it tells you what to expect when the pen is actually in your hand.

What the original study did

In 1986, the psychologists James Pennebaker and Sandra Beall asked 46 university students in the United States to write for about 15 minutes on four days in a row (Pennebaker & Beall, 1986, Journal of Abnormal Psychology). Some wrote about ordinary, trivial topics. Others wrote about something painful that had happened to them: some only the facts, some only their feelings, some both together.

Right after writing, the students who wrote about their feelings reported a worse mood than the others. The group that wrote facts and feelings together also had higher blood pressure after the first session.

Then, over the following months, that same facts-and-feelings group made fewer visits to the campus health centre. The difference was small and only just short of the usual line for statistical confidence, and the authors themselves called it promising rather than settled. The groups were tiny, around eleven or twelve students each, and the study measured trips to a health centre, not anxiety.

So I take two things from that first study. Writing about pain stings at first. And the version that seemed to do something was the one where people put what happened and how it felt side by side, like a story, rather than only venting or only reporting.

What happened when many studies were added up

One study of 46 students cannot tell you much on its own, so researchers kept testing the idea. In 2006, Joanne Frattaroli pooled 146 randomised studies of this kind of writing (Frattaroli, 2006, Psychological Bulletin). She found a real benefit on average, and it was small.

I want to sit with the word small for a moment, because it is easy to skip. It means writing is not a cure for worry, and it is not proven to reduce anxiety for everyone who tries it. It means that across a lot of people, on average, it seems to help a little. For some it helps more. For some it does nothing.

A review written for clinicians adds a few useful details (Baikie & Wilhelm, 2005, Advances in Psychiatric Treatment). Studies usually use 15 to 20 minutes, three to five times, often on consecutive days. A dip in mood right after writing is normal and did not seem to cause harm later on. People should be told they can stop at any time. And the results vary from group to group: for some, including people after a relationship breakup, the benefits were limited or mixed, and some groups who had been through trauma did worse. The authors are clear that writing should not replace medical or psychological care.

Why a page might help at all

No one fully knows why, and I won’t pretend to. But here is a way of thinking about it that I find gentle and useful.

Worry in your head tends to loop (I wrote more about that pattern in is overthinking running your life?). It comes back round to the same sentence, the same picture, the same “what if”, usually at the worst hour of the night. A page is different. It has a top and a bottom. You can see where the worry starts and where it runs out of words. You can read it back and notice that two of the fears are really the same fear in different clothes. And when the fifteen minutes are up, you can close the notebook, which is something you cannot do with your own mind.

That is not magic, and it will not work every time. It simply gives the worry somewhere to go other than round and round your chest.

A four-day way to try it

This is based on the format used in the early studies, softened a little for an ordinary week. You need a notebook or loose paper, a pen, a timer, and somewhere you won’t be interrupted for twenty minutes.

Four days, fifteen minutes a day Four day cards, 15 minutes each: write about the worry without stopping; keep going; write what it means to you; finish. It can feel worse before better; stop if too much. Based on Pennebaker and Beall 1986. Four days, fifteen minutes a day Day 1 15 min Write about what’s worrying you. Don’t stop. Day 2 15 min Same worry, or a new one. Keep going. Day 3 15 min Write what it means to you, not just facts. Day 4 15 min Write once more, then fold it away. It can feel worse before it feels better. If it’s too much, stop. Writing helps some people a little. It doesn’t replace help. Based on Pennebaker and Beall, 1986, and later expressive writing research
Four days, fifteen minutes a day: the expressive writing format from Pennebaker and Beall (1986), softened for an ordinary week.

Before you start: pick a time when you have a little space afterwards. Not right before an exam, a work call, or bed. You may feel heavier when you stop, and you want room to let that pass.

Day 1, 15 minutes. Write about what is worrying you. Don’t stop to fix spelling or make it sound good. If you run out of things to say, write the last sentence again until something new comes.

Day 2, 15 minutes. Write about the same worry, or a new one if that is what is loudest now. Keep going even if it feels repetitive.

Day 3, 15 minutes. This time, try to put what happened and how it felt next to each other. What does this worry mean to you? What is it afraid of? Where do you feel it in your body as you write?

Day 4, 15 minutes. Write once more. You might notice the story has shifted, or that it hasn’t, and either is fine. When the timer goes, fold the pages away. You do not have to read them again, keep them, or show them to anyone.

After each session: do something with your body for a few minutes. Wash your face, drink some water, walk to the window and back. Let the writing stay on the paper. If you need more ways to settle afterwards, here are six ways to calm down that don’t rely on your breath.

When to stop

Stop any time it gets too much. You do not need a reason, and putting the pen down halfway is not failing the exercise.

A few other moments to pay attention to:

  • If the worry is about something very recent and very painful. Harvard Health’s summary of this research suggests waiting a month or two after a traumatic event before trying this kind of writing (Harvard Health Publishing). Until then, being looked after comes first.
  • If you feel worse after every session and it doesn’t lift. A dip right after is common. Feeling lower and lower over several days is worth listening to. It is a reason to pause and talk to someone.
  • If you are writing the same page every day and nothing moves. That can mean the worry needs more than paper. It might need a person.
  • If what comes up is heavy, old, or frightening. Please put the pen down and talk to a qualified mental health professional. Writing can sit beside help, but it can’t replace it.

What I hope you take from this

You don’t need to expect to feel better when you finish. If anything, expect a little ache, and know that it is a normal part of how this works. A small, steady, honest benefit is the most the research promises, and I think that is enough to be worth trying.

If four days of open writing feels like too much right now, you can start smaller. I put together some journal prompts for anxious days that each fit in two lines.

Sources

What you have just read is psychoeducation: general information and reflection, written for a lot of people at once. It is not therapy, an assessment, or a diagnosis, and it is not advice about your particular situation. Reading it does not make us a practitioner and a client.

If you are carrying something heavy, please talk to a qualified mental health professional who can actually see you and your circumstances. And if you are in crisis or thinking about harming yourself, please do not start here. In India, Tele-MANAS is free and open 24 hours on 14416, in English and many Indian languages. Anywhere else, findahelpline.com has the number for your country.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top